"These are the reasons we love our cricket: the sounds and images of summer." - Richie Benaud
Friday, June 14, 2013
This man is the future of Australian cricket
Steve Smith made 104 not out on the first day of the Australia A match against Ireland yesterday. His second hundred of the Australia A tour of the British Isles. The man keeps reinforcing my belief, not only that he deserves a regular place on the Australian Test squad, but that he could one day captain Australia. Twitter's Richie Benaud thinks so, too. While his Test average may not be great (32.30), remember he outperformed the whole Australian side in India apart from Michael Clarke, making an impressive 92 in the Third Test. In any case, his overall first-class average measures at 40.98 - not too bad.
If you ask me, he should have been in the Ashes squad, preferably in place of Phil Hughes. I'm hoping his performance in the Australia A tour may single him out for a call-up, at least.
Tuesday, June 11, 2013
Whither Shane Watson?
It hasn't been mentioned much, but Shane Watson got a century just recently. He scored 135 runs off 98 balls in the ICC Champions Trophy warm-up match against the West Indies. Of course, in the next match he scored 4 (India) and in the next one, he scored 24 (England). Go figure.
It seems as though the Australian cricket-following fraternity is cleanly divided over the Shane Watson Conundrum. There are his loyal supporters, such as myself, who see Watson as the second best batsman on the Australian side by a good margin, but who has unfortunately been beleaguered by a spat of poor showings of late, interspersed by the occasional triumphant hundred; and there are his ruthless detractors, who would rather see him permanently dropped from the Australian side and would purge all evidence that he ever wore the baggy green.
The figures I mentioned above for the last three matches of the ICC Champions Trophy demonstrate this divide. His detractors point only to his poor figures, especially his shoddy Test figures in recent times. His supporters like me point to his occasional display of grand form to demonstrate that he has the skill and the capability to do great things and lead the Australian side.
For what it's worth, after consideration of the matter, I thought Watson's retirement from the vice-captaincy was the right decision. I was disappointed at the time, as I had always seen Watson as the natural deputy and successor to Michael Clarke (and I still do, as a matter of fact). But I think Watson needs the space and the time to recover his form. I wouldn't rule out Shane Watson eventually resuming the vice-captaincy, or even one day captaining Australia (providing he isn't too old, or retired, by then).
Like many Shane Watson supporters, I think he should be placed where he plays best: as an opener. He has batted forty-six Test innings as an opener at an average of 43.07. Not too bad, eh? He has limited experience elsewhere in the order, and with not nearly as much success: eight innings at no.3 for 28.50; seven innings at no.4 for 27.86; one innings at no.5 for 5; seven innings at no.6 for 24.29; and six innings at no.7 for 14.50. To bat forty-six innings as an opener for a consistent average of 43.07 should suggest that the opener position is his natural position, especially when compared with his less-than-spectacular averages at other places in the order. This is confirmed by the fact that he has an average of 46.10 at the opening position over 91 ODI innings. Impressive, no?
In the Ashes I would pair him with Chris Rogers in the opening position (ignore my previous post saying otherwise, I had admittedly not even considered Rogers then). That's what I call a formidable opening pair, or at least as formidable as Australia is capable of at this point in time. But I have a cynical feeling that Watson will continue to be played down the order to make way for David Warner and/or Ed Cowan (neither of whom inspire tremendous confidence as openers).
Nevertheless, this may be the defining period of Watson's career. He must make or break. His performance in the upcoming back-to-back Ashes series must be up to par - and preferably beyond - or the siren calls of the drop-Watson brigade will be all the more pertinent, and the selectors might just have a mind to start heeding them.
Sunday, May 19, 2013
Spoke too soon...
Re my previous post... it seems I spoke too soon. Who would have thought, having bowled England all out for 232 and 213, New Zealand would go on to lose the Test by 170 runs on the third day...? That was quite a - shall we say spectacular - collapse from the Kiwis. I don't think I've ever seen a more tortuous second innings. By the sixth wicket down I was just pleading for the Poms to put New Zealand out of their misery, having had everything to gain just to be bowled all out for a scrawny 68.
From an Australian perspective, the lessons are clear: fear Stuart Broad and James Anderson, master the moving ball, and don't cock it up. One silver lining, though, is that England failed to make big scores against the New Zealand seamers. We'll have to wait for the next Test at Headingley to see how the England batsmen perform again against the New Zealand bowlers, but the vulnerability the England batsmen showed in this Test should hearten the Australian bowlers.
From an Australian perspective, the lessons are clear: fear Stuart Broad and James Anderson, master the moving ball, and don't cock it up. One silver lining, though, is that England failed to make big scores against the New Zealand seamers. We'll have to wait for the next Test at Headingley to see how the England batsmen perform again against the New Zealand bowlers, but the vulnerability the England batsmen showed in this Test should hearten the Australian bowlers.
Saturday, May 18, 2013
Thanks, Kiwis
What was supposed to be a warm-up two-Test New Zealand tour has, for England, dampened their confidence ahead of the Ashes. For Australia, it's raised ours. After coming out of a comfortable series win in India, England were expected to roll New Zealand out of the way in two series against the other antipodeans, before triumphing in the Ashes over an embarassed Australia - the glittering ruby atop the trophy of England's cricketing glories. But the underdog Kiwis, like the feisty Jack Russel, have put up a laudable fight, nearly prevailing over England at home, and now frustrating their hopes again at Lord's.
New Zealand have bowled splendidly so far in the First Test at Lord's, revealing the England team's soft spots ahead of the Ashes. A victory in this Test is certainly not off the table. This supporter of the "worst Australian team since 1877" should be heartened to see England being tripped up - indeed, softened up - by the Kiwis, as should all Australian fans. Especially as the Australian Ashes squad is nowhere near as bad as everyone, not least the English, is making it out to be. We have a squadron of skilled pace bowlers, albeit some of them inexperienced in international cricket, who have the capacity to wreak havoc in English conditions. If England's performance in this Test against New Zealand is any indicator, we should have few problems taking wickets. Defending our own will need to be our focus.
Friday, May 10, 2013
Who would you knight?
There is a likelihood that Tony Abbot, when he becomes Prime Minister, will restore the knighthood order to the Order of Australia, which was abolished by Bob Hawke in the 1980s. Whatever your opinions on Australia's ties to the monarchy, it has traditionally been custom for eminent Australian cricketers to be knighted, either under an imperial order of knighthood or by our native Australian order. The most obvious example is the great Sir Donald Bradman. So I've been thinking about which Australian cricketers I would like to see knighted for their services to the great game, were knighthoods to return to the Australian Honours System.
The two that stand out for me are Sir Richie Benaud and Sir Ricky Ponting. I might also include the other great Australian captains of the modern era: Sir Allan Border and Sir Steve Waugh. It might even be worth considering Sir Shane Warne, Sir Glen McGrath, Sir Adam Gilchrist, Sir Ian Chappell.
Who would you knight?
Tuesday, April 23, 2013
Evaluation of the Ashes Squad
The Ashes Squad has been announced:
Michael Clarke (c)
Brad Haddin (vc)
Jackson Bird
Ed Cowan
James Faulkner
Ryan Harris
Phil Hughes
Usman Khawaja
Nathan Lyon
James Pattinson
Chris Rogers
Peter Siddle
Mitchell Starc
Matthew Wade
David Warner
Shane Watson
Some good points and bad points about this squad. I suppose Brad Haddin is a decent choice as vice-captain - he is just as experienced as Shane Watson (slightly more, in fact, with 44 Tests under his belt compared to Watson's 41), so he certainly has the experience needed for the leadership role. But he wouldn't have been my first choice for wicket-keeper: he's 35 for goodness' sake; five Ashes Tests, four first-class tour matches and three Australia A matches will be a great demand on the fellow's strength and endurance.
The bowling attack is good. Since Shane Watson will be bowling that gives us seven pace bowlers (Bird, Faulkner, Harris, Starc, Siddle, Pattinson, Watson) and one spinner (Lyon). I'm pleased with the inclusion of Jackson Bird in the squad; he's a very talented up-and-coming bowler whose ability to swing the ball will be a great asset in England. I'm a bit disappointed with the exclusion of Mitchell Johnson, though, who apparently "narrowly missed selection"; despite his performance in India (not that he was given much of a chance) he can be very dangerous when he is in form.
The inclusion of Usman Khawaja is reassuring, but will he be chosen for a Test? How many times has Khawaja been chosen for a squad before and not been selected for a single Test? I genuinely hope this is not one of those times, as he will be very useful against England in English conditions.
What is really disheartening about this squad is the inclusion of Phil Hughes. I cannot stress this enough: he is rubbish. He can't play against spin - his performance in India proved that. Here are his figures for the entire Indian tour: 6 and 0, 19 and 0, 2 and 69, 45 and 6. That's a total of 147 runs over four Tests at an average of 18.38. In five of his eight innings he didn't pass 10 runs. Swann and Panesar will tear him apart. It seems like the selectors are just continuing to trot him out because they don't have the courage to drop him and try someone else (hint: Shaun Marsh). That may sound harsh but if Australia wants to climb back to the no.1 position, something the selectors apparently regard as rather important, we need to stop trotting out shoddy players like Hughes. Send him back to Sheffield Shield and when he's shown he's improved, then we can give him another shot in the national side.
What is even more disheartening about Hughes' inclusion is the absence of Steve Smith in his place. He performed better than any Australian batsman in India apart from Michael Clarke. Better than Warner and Cowan, better than Watson, better than Wade, and a bloody lot better than Hughes. I can see him as a permanent fixture of the Australian side, even a future captain, yet the selectors have seen fit to sideline him in favour of the "established" rubbish batsmen. That said, it is encouraging that he was made vice-captain of the Australia A squad, but why make him VC of the Second XI over a whole host of players who are in the Ashes squad, if not to include him in the Ashes squad itself? And why, for the last time, was Hughes included but not Smith???
Finally, turning to Shane Watson, it is a good thing that he is to be bowling again and re-assuming the all-rounder role, but I suppose this means he won't be opening the batting, as I had hoped. The inclusion of both Warner and Cowan (and Hughes) seems to confirm this. Despite criticism (some of it very unfair to my mind) of his recent form, I still have confidence in him. He is still the second best batsman on the Australian side. He made a hundred in the IPL just yesterday, if that is any show of his batting abilities. I very much hope that my faith in Watson will be vindicated in the Ashes and prove his detractors wrong. I am confident he will rise to the occasion. Just you watch.
What I take away from this squad overall is that the selectors have the right ideas for the Ashes, but still lack the courage to take bold steps with Australia's future in mind. The inclusion of Hughes and the absence of Smith is a case in point (although the total exclusion of Glenn Maxwell is slightly reassuring). It is a good squad, but could be better. We certainly have a chance of winning back the Ashes with this squad, or at least of avoiding by a good margin another devestating series defeat as in India - but every player must meet the challenge. It's going to be a tough one.
Michael Clarke (c)
Brad Haddin (vc)
Jackson Bird
Ed Cowan
James Faulkner
Ryan Harris
Phil Hughes
Usman Khawaja
Nathan Lyon
James Pattinson
Chris Rogers
Peter Siddle
Mitchell Starc
Matthew Wade
David Warner
Shane Watson
Some good points and bad points about this squad. I suppose Brad Haddin is a decent choice as vice-captain - he is just as experienced as Shane Watson (slightly more, in fact, with 44 Tests under his belt compared to Watson's 41), so he certainly has the experience needed for the leadership role. But he wouldn't have been my first choice for wicket-keeper: he's 35 for goodness' sake; five Ashes Tests, four first-class tour matches and three Australia A matches will be a great demand on the fellow's strength and endurance.
The bowling attack is good. Since Shane Watson will be bowling that gives us seven pace bowlers (Bird, Faulkner, Harris, Starc, Siddle, Pattinson, Watson) and one spinner (Lyon). I'm pleased with the inclusion of Jackson Bird in the squad; he's a very talented up-and-coming bowler whose ability to swing the ball will be a great asset in England. I'm a bit disappointed with the exclusion of Mitchell Johnson, though, who apparently "narrowly missed selection"; despite his performance in India (not that he was given much of a chance) he can be very dangerous when he is in form.
The inclusion of Usman Khawaja is reassuring, but will he be chosen for a Test? How many times has Khawaja been chosen for a squad before and not been selected for a single Test? I genuinely hope this is not one of those times, as he will be very useful against England in English conditions.
What is really disheartening about this squad is the inclusion of Phil Hughes. I cannot stress this enough: he is rubbish. He can't play against spin - his performance in India proved that. Here are his figures for the entire Indian tour: 6 and 0, 19 and 0, 2 and 69, 45 and 6. That's a total of 147 runs over four Tests at an average of 18.38. In five of his eight innings he didn't pass 10 runs. Swann and Panesar will tear him apart. It seems like the selectors are just continuing to trot him out because they don't have the courage to drop him and try someone else (hint: Shaun Marsh). That may sound harsh but if Australia wants to climb back to the no.1 position, something the selectors apparently regard as rather important, we need to stop trotting out shoddy players like Hughes. Send him back to Sheffield Shield and when he's shown he's improved, then we can give him another shot in the national side.
What is even more disheartening about Hughes' inclusion is the absence of Steve Smith in his place. He performed better than any Australian batsman in India apart from Michael Clarke. Better than Warner and Cowan, better than Watson, better than Wade, and a bloody lot better than Hughes. I can see him as a permanent fixture of the Australian side, even a future captain, yet the selectors have seen fit to sideline him in favour of the "established" rubbish batsmen. That said, it is encouraging that he was made vice-captain of the Australia A squad, but why make him VC of the Second XI over a whole host of players who are in the Ashes squad, if not to include him in the Ashes squad itself? And why, for the last time, was Hughes included but not Smith???
Finally, turning to Shane Watson, it is a good thing that he is to be bowling again and re-assuming the all-rounder role, but I suppose this means he won't be opening the batting, as I had hoped. The inclusion of both Warner and Cowan (and Hughes) seems to confirm this. Despite criticism (some of it very unfair to my mind) of his recent form, I still have confidence in him. He is still the second best batsman on the Australian side. He made a hundred in the IPL just yesterday, if that is any show of his batting abilities. I very much hope that my faith in Watson will be vindicated in the Ashes and prove his detractors wrong. I am confident he will rise to the occasion. Just you watch.
What I take away from this squad overall is that the selectors have the right ideas for the Ashes, but still lack the courage to take bold steps with Australia's future in mind. The inclusion of Hughes and the absence of Smith is a case in point (although the total exclusion of Glenn Maxwell is slightly reassuring). It is a good squad, but could be better. We certainly have a chance of winning back the Ashes with this squad, or at least of avoiding by a good margin another devestating series defeat as in India - but every player must meet the challenge. It's going to be a tough one.
Wednesday, April 17, 2013
My Ashes Side
My picks for the Australian team in the First Ashes Test at Trent Bridge.
1. Shane Watson
2. Ed Cowan
3. Shaun Marsh
4. Michael Clarke (c)
5. Usman Khawaja
6. Steven Smith
7. Tim Paine (wk)
8. Mitchell Starc
9. Peter Siddle
10. James Pattinson
11. Nathan Lyon
12. Mitchell Johnson
First of all, Shane Watson has copped a lot of criticism lately, not least from Twitter's Richie Benaud (not the real one). True, he performed poorly in India, but so did the whole side apart from Michael Clarke and perhaps Steve Smith. But what sticks in my mind is Shane Watson's performance in the ODI series against the West Indies in February, in which he made 122 and 76 as an opening batsman in his first two matches since returning to the side after a lengthy break. He went on to make 84 and 60 in the three-day warm up match in India, again as an opening batsman. There's no doubt that he can bat. He has form. To my mind he is still by a good length the second best batsman on the Australian side. But we need him in a place where he can score runs, and that seems undeniably to be as an opener.
I've dropped David Warner because I feel, on balance, he's not a solid Test batsman. He has too much T20 in him; some of the shots he got himself out on in India weren't that spectacular. That said, he's an impressive T20 and ODI batsman, but every time he's at the striker's end in a Test match I can't help but feel apprehensive that he's about to get himself out on every ball. Ed Cowan is a more solid opener who is better suited to Test cricket. Plus his performance in the English County season definitely inspires confidence for his inclusion in the Ashes squad.
Hughes performed dismally in India, showing himself to be seemingly incapable of playing against spin. The Indians poked open huge holes in his batting technique, and he can't possibly expect to be included in the Ashes squad after that performance. Shaun Marsh would be a better choice for #3.
Usman Khawaja has great technique against pace bowling and will undoubtedly be an asset in England. Khawaja is a high quality batsman who has been sidelined for too long, and deserves the chance to prove himself on an Ashes tour.
Steven Smith proved himself in India to be a capable and solid Test batsman. He looked comfortable and in control at the crease, and shows enormous promise. I think he has deserved a place in the Ashes squad, if not at least a regular place on the Australian Test squad. He also has a handy leg break up his sleeve (Sachin Tendulkar's dismissal anyone?).
I'm going on my gut feeling with Tim Paine over Matthew Wade. Wade has not been wicket-keeper long enough to "establish" himself as premier Test keeper so it is not yet heresy to shuffle him out.
I've kept Mitchell Johnson in, if only at twelfth man, despite recent criticism of a decline in his wicket-taking prowess. He can be a very dangerous bowler when he is in form. His performance in the IPL season is encouraging, and he will be a great asset in England.
1. Shane Watson
2. Ed Cowan
3. Shaun Marsh
4. Michael Clarke (c)
5. Usman Khawaja
6. Steven Smith
7. Tim Paine (wk)
8. Mitchell Starc
9. Peter Siddle
10. James Pattinson
11. Nathan Lyon
12. Mitchell Johnson
First of all, Shane Watson has copped a lot of criticism lately, not least from Twitter's Richie Benaud (not the real one). True, he performed poorly in India, but so did the whole side apart from Michael Clarke and perhaps Steve Smith. But what sticks in my mind is Shane Watson's performance in the ODI series against the West Indies in February, in which he made 122 and 76 as an opening batsman in his first two matches since returning to the side after a lengthy break. He went on to make 84 and 60 in the three-day warm up match in India, again as an opening batsman. There's no doubt that he can bat. He has form. To my mind he is still by a good length the second best batsman on the Australian side. But we need him in a place where he can score runs, and that seems undeniably to be as an opener.
I've dropped David Warner because I feel, on balance, he's not a solid Test batsman. He has too much T20 in him; some of the shots he got himself out on in India weren't that spectacular. That said, he's an impressive T20 and ODI batsman, but every time he's at the striker's end in a Test match I can't help but feel apprehensive that he's about to get himself out on every ball. Ed Cowan is a more solid opener who is better suited to Test cricket. Plus his performance in the English County season definitely inspires confidence for his inclusion in the Ashes squad.
Hughes performed dismally in India, showing himself to be seemingly incapable of playing against spin. The Indians poked open huge holes in his batting technique, and he can't possibly expect to be included in the Ashes squad after that performance. Shaun Marsh would be a better choice for #3.
Usman Khawaja has great technique against pace bowling and will undoubtedly be an asset in England. Khawaja is a high quality batsman who has been sidelined for too long, and deserves the chance to prove himself on an Ashes tour.
Steven Smith proved himself in India to be a capable and solid Test batsman. He looked comfortable and in control at the crease, and shows enormous promise. I think he has deserved a place in the Ashes squad, if not at least a regular place on the Australian Test squad. He also has a handy leg break up his sleeve (Sachin Tendulkar's dismissal anyone?).
I'm going on my gut feeling with Tim Paine over Matthew Wade. Wade has not been wicket-keeper long enough to "establish" himself as premier Test keeper so it is not yet heresy to shuffle him out.
I've kept Mitchell Johnson in, if only at twelfth man, despite recent criticism of a decline in his wicket-taking prowess. He can be a very dangerous bowler when he is in form. His performance in the IPL season is encouraging, and he will be a great asset in England.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)